Asserzione e gradi di forza illocutoria / Assertion and gradual variations in illocutionary force

  • Paolo Labinaz
Keywords: assertion, assertive speech acts, illocutionary force, speech act theory, J.L. Austin

Abstract

While assertive speech acts are standardly divided into types corresponding to the performative formulas that make their illocutionary force explicit, in ordinary conversation people are usually faced with “non-prototypical” cases, performed in issuing utterances such as “The pen might be on the table” or “I seem to remember that the pen is on the table”, which do not correspond to clear-cut cases of illocutionary act-type. The aim of this paper is to deal with the nuances and complexities of the “assertive family” by taking the illocutionary force of assertion as the starting point to account for its other members, particularly non-prototypical ones. In the first part, I examine whether the three main approaches to assertion, according to which asserting amounts, respectively, to (i) expressing a belief, (ii) making a move governed by a certain rule and (iii) undertaking a commitment, can be extended to achieve this goal, and argue that they cannot. In the second part, I propose an alternative approach to assertion, inspired by J.L. Austin’s conception of the illocutionary act and its effects, that seems to provide a more promising framework accounting for assertive speech acts, be they prototypical or not, in terms of gradual variations of strength in their illocutionary force.

References

AUSTIN, John (1975), How to Do Things with Words, Oxford University Press, Oxford (Come fare cose con le parole, trad. di, Villata Carla, Marietti, Genova 1987).

BACH, Kent, HARNISH, Robert (1979), Linguistic Communication and Speech Acts, The MIT Press, Cambridge.

BRANDOM, Robert (1983), «Asserting», in Noûs, vol. 17, n. 4, pp. 637-650.

BRANDOM, Robert (1994), Making It Explicit, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.

BROWN, Jessica, CAPPELEN, Herman (2011) (a cura), Assertion: New Philosophical Essays, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

CAFFI, Claudia (2013), Mitigation, in SBISÀ Marina, TURNER Ken (a cura), Handbook of Pragmatics: Pragmatics of Speech Actions, Gruyter, Berlin, pp. 257-285.

DAVIDSON, Donald (1984), Convention and Communication in DAVIDSON Donald (a cura), Inquiries into truth and interpretation, Clarendon Press, Oxford, pp. 265-280.

DEROSE, Keith (2002), «Assertion, Knowledge, and Context», in The Philosophical Review, vol. 111, n. 2, pp. 167-203.

FRICKER, Elizabeth (2006), «Second-Hand Knowledge», in Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, vol. 73, pp. 592-618.

GERKEN, Mikkel (2014), «Same, Same but Different: The Epistemic Norms of Assertion, Action and Practical Reasoning», in Philosophical Studies, vol. 168, n. 3, pp. 725-744.

GREEN, Mitchell (2007), Self-Expression, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

GREEN Mitchell (2013), Assertions in SBISÀ Marina, TURNER, Ken (a cura) Handbook of Pragmatics: Pragmatics of Speech Actions, Gruyter, Berlin, pp. 387-410.

LABINAZ, Paolo, SBISÀ, Marina (2014), Certainty and Uncertainty in Assertive Speech Acts in ZUCZKOWSKI Andrzej, BONGELLI Ramona, RICCIONI Ilaria, CANESTRARI Carla (a cura), Communicating Certainty and Uncertainty in Medical, Supportive and Scientific Contexts, John Benjamins, Amsterdam, pp. 31-58.

LABINAZ, Paolo, SBISÀ, Marina (in pubblicazione), «Credibilità e disseminazione di conoscenze nei social network», in Iride.

LABINAZ, Paolo (manoscritto), «Is There a Place for Degrees of Strength in Brandom’s Game of Giving and Asking for Reasons?».

LACKEY, Jennifer (2007), «Norms of Assertion», in Nous, vol. 41, n. 4, pp. 594-626.

MACFARLANE, John (2005), «Making Sense of Relative Truth», in Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, vol. 105, n. 1, pp. 321-339.

MACFARLANE, John (2011), «What is Assertion?» in BROWN, Jessica, CAPPELEN Herman (a cura), Assertion, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 79-96.

OWENS, David (2006), «Testimony and Assertion», in Philosophical Studies, vol. 130, pp. 105-129.

PAGIN, Peter (2014), «Assertion» in The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, disponibile su http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2014/entries/assertion/.

PEIRCE, Charles (1934), Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce in HARTSHORNE Charles, WEISS Paul (a cura), Pragmatism and Pragmaticism, Harvard University Press, Cambridge.

SBISÀ, Marina (2001), «Illocutionary Force and Degrees of Strength in Language Use», in Journal of Pragmatics, vol. 33, n. 12, pp. 1791-1814.

SBISÀ, Marina (2007), «How to Read Austin», in Pragmatics, vol. 17, n. 3, pp. 461-473.

SBISÀ, Marina (2014), «Evidentiality and Illocution», in Intercultural Pragmatics, vol. 11, n. 3, pp. 463-483.

SEARLE, John (1969), Speech Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy of Language, Cambridge University Press; Cambridge (Atti linguistici, trad. di, Cardona Giorgio R., Boringhieri, Torino 1976).

SEARLE, John (1979), Expression and Meaning, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

SEARLE, John, VANDERVEKEN, Daniel (1985), Foundations of Illocutionary Logic, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.

TURRI, John (2014), «Knowledge and Suberogatory Assertion», in Philosophical Studies, vol. 167, n. 3, pp. 557-567.

WEINER, Matthew (2005), «Must We Know What We Say?», in Philosophical Review, vol. 114, n. 2, pp. 227-251.

WILLIAMS, Bernard (2002), Truth and Truthfulness, Princeton University Press, Princeton.

WILLIAMSON, Timothy (2000), Knowledge and its Limits, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

WITEK, Maciej (2015), «An Interactional Account of Illocutionary Practice», in Language Sciences, vol. 47, pp. 43-55.

Published
2016-10-31
How to Cite
Labinaz, P. (2016) “Asserzione e gradi di forza illocutoria / Assertion and gradual variations in illocutionary force”, Rivista Italiana di Filosofia del Linguaggio, 00. Available at: http://www.rifl.unical.it/index.php/rifl/article/view/351 (Accessed: 24January2021).